Questions tagged [temperament]

For questions generally relating to systems of note frequency assignment. Questions will often include the tuning and/or alternative-tunings tag.

"Temperament" generally refers to the system used to assign a frequency value to each specific named pitch. An octave, or equivalent term, is defined in most musical systems as an interval of two pitches in which the higher pitch is exactly double the frequency of the lower pitch, or, equivalently, as the interval between the first harmonic (the fundamental) and the second harmonic (the harmonic with exactly half the wavelength of the first).

In the modern Western or European music system as of shortly before the Renaissance, the octave is subdivided into twelve notes or pitches, of which seven are lettered A through G (or in some European systems using "solfeggio" syllables popularized by The Sound Of Music as "Do, Re Mi". The remaining five tones of the scale are located in between lettered notes, and are indicated as "sharp" (a half step higher) or "flat" (a half step lower) than a lettered note. The "sharp" of one lettered note is usually the same pitch as the "flat" of the next higher lettered note, except in two cases, between B and C and between E and F, where only one half-step separated the two, and so "B-sharp" is the same note as C and "E-Sharp" is the same note as F.

Originally, the subdivision of notes between octaves was done linearly, based on mathematical principles such as those of Pythagoras which predicted notes such as the "perfect fourth" and "perfect fifth" that sounded pleasing because they represented subdivisions of an octave into wavelengths that were both integer fractions of the octave and summed to the octave itself. While this worked within the older "modal" system of early music theory, as the modern 12-tone system took shape allowing any note to be used as the "root" of a "key", this system of "just temperament" presented a problem; when tuned to a particular key, such as C, not all notes within that key were exactly twice or half the frequency of their own "octaves", because the system of octaves was based on an exponential scale, while the notes within it were distributed linearly. This caused pieces played in a key other than the one to which the instrument was tuned to sound incorrect and out of tune.

In the late Renaissance and early Baroque periods, this was solved by mathematicians who identified the problem (the difference between exponential and linear frequency curves) and developed a solution; the "equal temperament scale", described by a single exponential equation that would assign the notes within each octave a frequency that fell on the "best-fit" line between octaves. The net result was that every named pitch was exactly half or double the frequency of the higher or lower octave of the same named pitch. The problem, for some, was that this system didn't reproduce the exact partial harmonics heard in the just temperament system, so intervals like the fourth and fifth sounded slightly out of tune, and other intervals like the third sounded even more so. The equal-temperament system met with only limited success until Johann Sebastian Bach wrote a book of etudes, preludes and fugues for "The Well-Tempered Clavier", incorporating songs in each of the 24 named keys (A Major, A Minor, Bb Major/Minor, etc) that were now possible to be played one after the other on the same instrument in a single concert or recital. Bach's musical descendants in the Baroque and Classical periods, including Mozart and Haydn, studied this work closely and incorporated novel ideas such as key changes based on this system, solidifying equal temperament as the preferred tuning system of Western music. Nowadays, modern listening ears are accustomed to the equal-temperament system, and the slight dissonance produced by the equally-tempered third, fourth and fifth in mechanically-tuned instruments like the piano are considered normal. On instruments for which dynamic tuning is possible, such as the bowed-string family, the trombone, and the human voice, it's possible to tune these intervals perfectly on the spot, and this is often encouraged especially in choral groups to bring out the harmonics that these perfectly-tuned intervals produce.

The remaining variable in most Western music performance is the "tuning standard" or "reference frequency"; this frequency, typically a reference for the pitch "A4", determines the frequency of all other notes according to the equal temperament equation. The usual standard for most instruments is A-440, so A4 is exactly 440Hz, A3 is 220, A5 is 880, etc. However, performing groups are free to adopt any standard they choose (as long as all instruments are tuned to the same standard), and standards anywhere from A-438 to A-445 are relatively common. The standard is often altered at will based on an instrument that is difficult to tune, such as a pipe organ; climatic differences such as temperature and humidity can cause the instrument to vary naturally by a few Hz either way, and as retuning a large organ with thousands of pipes can take days or weeks, it's typically easier for an orchestra or chamber group playing with an organ to tune themselves to the organ's current A4 pitch. The organ tuner can then concentrate on simply keeping the instrument in tune with itself, requiring smaller changes to fewer pipes.

99 questions
55
votes
7 answers

Does it really make difference to play a song in a different key?

I hear sometimes players and composers say that this song won't sound good in F Major for example, and you should play it or write it in G Major (this was just an example). In other words, it seems that they assign aesthetic attributes to keys. My…
Saeed Neamati
  • 2,263
  • 5
  • 21
  • 28
51
votes
5 answers

Why are pianos traditionally tuned "out of tune" at the extremes?

My understanding is that the vast majority of western music uses equal temperament, i.e. all semitones have a frequency ratio of the 12th root of 2. However I can hear in my piano that the notes at the low and high extremes of the keyboard are ever…
Michael Slade
  • 831
  • 2
  • 7
  • 11
49
votes
9 answers

Why are orchestras tuned differently?

In 1936 American Standards Association (and the International Organization for Standardization in 1955) accepted that A would be tuned at 440 Hz (or cycles per second). Yet despite the fact that a standard has been accepted, orchestras frequently…
SRiss
  • 1,259
  • 1
  • 11
  • 16
42
votes
10 answers

Software that allows playing in different temperaments

Do you know of any software out there that will allow me to play in different musical temperaments (e.g. Well temperament and Meantone temperament)? I'm especially interested in software that accepts MIDI input.
Babu
  • 6,208
  • 2
  • 29
  • 36
29
votes
5 answers

Examples of songs or phrases played in different temperaments

I've read about the fact that 12 tone equal temperament is a relatively recent phenomenon, and that historically, each key would have a different character due to the unequal temperament. I'm curious about how equal temperament changes the character…
Brian Campbell
  • 1,079
  • 1
  • 10
  • 17
27
votes
4 answers

Is there a sound theoretical reason why a capella choirs "drift off" of the starting pitches in a piece?

Is the "comma pump" an empirical problem, or merely theoretical? It's a standard music theory exercise to show that certain chord progressions don't actually quite work. For example, in the I-IV-ii-V-I progression, following the "naive" method of…
Micah
  • 1,569
  • 12
  • 27
26
votes
10 answers

With modern electronic technology is temperament unnecessary?

I am a Physics student but also love math and music, and know a little bit about tuning because it is related to mathematics. So as far as I understand, Just Intonation is more consonant than Temperaments. The major problem of Just Intonation is…
24
votes
8 answers

B -> C and E -> F, No Sharp?

The keyboard has these notes: A, A#, B, C, C#, D, D#, E, F, F#, G, G# Why do B and C and E and F not have a sharp note between them? If they did, the keyboard would look like this: A A# B B# C C# D D# E E# F F# G G# Bold being black keys. Would…
Jacob Swanson
  • 1,701
  • 4
  • 15
  • 31
23
votes
3 answers

Why is B♯ higher than C♭ in 31-ET?

I was looking into microtonal series, and started reading a bit on the 31-ET series, and came across something that doesn't quite make sense to me. I noticed this chart on the wiki page for 31-ET that listed all of the notes in the chromatic…
Siyual
  • 902
  • 1
  • 7
  • 11
22
votes
8 answers

Do the violins imitate equal temperament when accompanying the piano?

My previous question about equal temperament was answered with a flourish, so here's the follow-up one: Because math and harmony don't seem to mix very well, piano tuners have to cheat a little bit, pulling down the fifths, nudging the fourths a bit…
Ricky
  • 587
  • 6
  • 13
21
votes
5 answers

Why did equal temperament become the standard tuning system for keyboard instruments?

Some people seem to make the case that having some keys beat more than others (as is in the case in the older well-tempered tuning systems) is a feature not a bug. But on the other hand, the equal tempered tuning system seems completely dominant…
J. Lenthe
  • 594
  • 3
  • 12
18
votes
6 answers

Do classical pieces sound different today than the originals due to temperament?

I was reading how classical music used to not be in equal temperament. So each of their keys sounded completely different and that's why they named their pieces after the keys they were playing. Whereas today because of equal temperament all major…
user34288
16
votes
2 answers

Why does this tonal scale from 1737 have both F and E♯?

I've recently encountered Jean Féry-Rebel's "Les Élémens". (Check out that wild opening; it's hard to believe it was written in 1737!) In the fifth measure of the third staff, why does this descending scale include both F and E♯? (Notice that it…
Richard
  • 82,618
  • 16
  • 186
  • 360
16
votes
10 answers

From the piano tuner's viewpoint, what needs to be done in order to achieve "equal temperament"?

I get the feeling that the actual explanation is a lot simpler than what the manuals and textbooks offer. I've been trying to make sense of it all, and now I find myself thoroughly confused. Here goes: When you play an octave on the piano (say, a C…
Ricky
  • 587
  • 6
  • 13
13
votes
2 answers

Do the EDO and TET acronyms mean the same thing?

In the context of dividing an octave into n intervals, I understand n EDO to mean n Equal Divisions per Octave and n TET to mean n Tones Equal Temperament. Do the EDO and TET acronyms mean the same thing or is there some subtle difference?
Brian THOMAS
  • 10,171
  • 1
  • 31
  • 65
1
2 3 4 5 6 7