5

The white keys on the piano have single letter names:

C, D, E, F, G, A, B

The black keys require a minimum of 2 letters to "spell" their names :

Db, Eb, Gb, Ab, Bb

or

C#, D#, F#, G#, A#

Is anybody aware of any common single-letter names for the black notes? I have been playing around with using

H, I, J, K, L

But I don't love it and thought I'd see if anybody knew of a convention that already exists.

freddyz
  • 139
  • 4
  • 5
    Whilst it does not answer your question, be aware that there are good reasons for using the sharp/flat notation. Using different names will convey less information. And also mean that no one else understands you. – endorph Nov 29 '16 at 21:33
  • 4
    German nomenclature calls the B "H", and the B flat "B" - but that's only one of the five. – Kilian Foth Nov 30 '16 at 05:52
  • @KilianFoth and thus the reason Bach could write an invention (I believe, possibly a fugue) using the letters of his name :-) – Carl Witthoft Nov 30 '16 at 12:46
  • 3
    Actually, Shostakovich did the same when adopting his own musical sigil "D S C H": German for "E flat" is "Es", which has two letters but *sounds* exactly like "S". – Kilian Foth Nov 30 '16 at 12:48
  • 1
    Following what @endorph said it's also worth remembering that on many instruments these notes are not the same. F# is the same as Gb on a piano but not, for example, on a violin. – JimM Dec 01 '16 at 11:13
  • @JimM so are you saying that on a violin, F# and Gb will have different pitch? – freddyz Dec 01 '16 at 22:26
  • 2
    @freddyz Yes that's what I'm saying. – JimM Dec 02 '16 at 18:33
  • Related [question](https://music.stackexchange.com/q/23976/2600). – guidot May 16 '22 at 07:51

7 Answers7

11

Not using letter names, but in set theory instead of giving out letter names to the 12 pitches they are just enumerated typically starting at C as such:

C  C#/Db  D  D#/Eb  E    F  F#/Gb  G  G#/Ab  A  A#/Bb  B
0    1    2    3    4    5    6    7    8    9   10   11

This allows a much easier path to do calculations and look at reoccurring ideas in a 12-tone equal temperament system where enharmonic notes correspond to the exact same frequency.

Elements in Space
  • 10,785
  • 2
  • 23
  • 67
Dom
  • 47,095
  • 22
  • 150
  • 281
  • I think in this context, "set theory" is better described as "modular arithmetic" – Nayuki Nov 30 '16 at 04:26
  • 2
    10 and 11 both are still made of two symbols (1 and 0, 1 and 1). OP is in search of `common single-letter`/symbol. If you count not in base 10, but in 16 (hexadecimal), it could be `0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 A B`, but I don't think its common. – Dancia Nov 30 '16 at 08:07
  • 3
    It is unfortunate that whoever invented this system called it "set theory," as it has just about nothing to do with mathematical Set Theory. – Carl Witthoft Nov 30 '16 at 12:48
  • 1
    @CarlWitthoft it kind of does when you actually look at analysis – Dom Nov 30 '16 at 12:54
  • 2
    Well, sorta... once you include operations it gets closer to a ring :-) – Carl Witthoft Nov 30 '16 at 14:05
  • @CarlWitthoft In fact, mathematical set theory, as well as number theory, group theory, and category theory, are all integral parts of modern music theory. You can find numerous articles, for example, in the journal Perspectives of New Music. – Aaron Apr 15 '21 at 19:15
  • 4
    @Dancia The notation you mention is very close to the standard, except that T and E are most typically used for 10 and 11, rather than A and B. – Aaron Apr 15 '21 at 19:16
  • @Dancia try 0, 1, 2, ..., 7, 8 , 9, B, H – Elements in Space Apr 16 '21 at 04:33
9

Perhaps the German names may be helpful. While not a single letter name, these are single syllable names and thus easy to sing. Using these is at least semi-standard.

https://www.library.yale.edu/cataloging/music/keylang.htm

There is the possibility of using a chromatic do-re-mi system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solf%C3%A8ge

The latter two systems do map more than one name to a single note.

ttw
  • 24,207
  • 1
  • 31
  • 76
3

Not that I'm aware of. The whole point is that being called a # or b actually gives information out. If you know some theory, it can explain what is happening when accidentals are used, and if they were different letter names, then key sigs would be tricky, I think. There actually is already 'H', in Germany and other countries, used for B - Bb being called B. Now how confusing is that? And once you start adding Doh - both fixed and moveable- into the equation, it's possibly best to let sleeping dogs lie...

Tim
  • 183,051
  • 16
  • 181
  • 444
3

The closest thing to this was Boethius in the 6th century. He tried to use the system you mention and just went through the alphabet.

But his system didn't have sharps and flats, just the note names. When accidentals were first introduced, on the note B, they used a rounded "b" for the flat, and a boxed "b", (#) for the sharp.

So, no, the notes have always been referred to with the two characters.

Caleb
  • 175
  • 1
  • 10
2

As far as written systems go, the closest you'll get to a single-character notation for the entire chromatic scale is the numeric system in Dom's answer, generally notated as 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 T E.

For spoken letter-names incorporating a single syllable, the most common system I've encountered is adding "-sh" for sharps and "-f" for flats. Thus:

C Ceesh D Deesh E (Eesh) F Feesh G Geesh A Aysh B (Beesh)
and
C (Ceef) B Beef A Ayf G Geef F (Feef) E Eef D Deef

Aaron
  • 70,616
  • 10
  • 97
  • 243
1

I'm finding this problem when learning the bass. The syllable of "flat" just gets in the way and interrupts any flow I have. I've taken to just adding an "eef" when I'm saying the notes I'm playing to myself, this keeps the info and makes the sound concise.

A Aeef B C Ceef D Deef E F Feef G Geef.

Works for me anyhow.

BeardedTit
  • 11
  • 1
1

I call this PƏÆTK-BEADG-CF system (circle of fourths/counter-clockwise) and GDAEB-KTÆƏP-FC system (circle of fifths/clockwise) (I just use dashes to group those patterns into chunks). The note names are based on the circle of fifths/fourths - and the occuring pattern: BEADG (circle of fourth/counter-clockwise pattern) - and the counterpart flat note names influenced by IPA/International Phonetic Alphabet.

How did I come to this solution?

As you may know, the notes in circle of fourths in flats are (starting from Bb): Bb Eb Ab Db Gb B E A D G C F

or the same in sharps: A# D# G# C# F# B E A D G C F

Immediately one can see the common ground between the sequences of flat notes and natural notes:

Bb Eb Ab Db Gb
B  E  A  D  G

So what I've done is I have taken those flat notes and assigned them new close phonemes (influenced by IPA/International Phonetic Alphabet):

Bb = P (voiceless counterpart letter of B)
Eb = Ə (pronounced [ə], as in words "a" [ə] or "the" [ðə], particularly derived from English word "the")
Ab = Æ (pronounced [æ], as in words "and" [ænd] or "man" [mæn])
Db = T (voiceless counterpart letter of D)
Gb = K (voiceless counterpart letter of G)

So the note letters starting from C, are:
C T D Ə E F K G Æ A P B

The circle of fourths (going counter-clockwise in the circle of fifths) are in my system (starting from P):
P Ə Æ T K B E A D G C F (PƏÆTK-BEADG-CF)

And the circle of fifths (going clockwise in the circle of fifths) are in my system (starting from G):
G D A E B K T Æ Ə P F C (GDAEB-KTÆƏP-FC)

The system helps to immediately to find the notes in a guitar.

Circle of 4ths. In a standard E tuned guitar, one can easily find those patterns (using my PƏÆTK-BEADG-CF notation system). Counting the notes per fret, starting from the 6th string, just remember to step one fret to left at the 2nd string:

E|  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B [C] T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P [B] C  T  D  Ə  E
B|  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K [G] Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F [K] G  Æ  A  P  B
G|  Æ  A  P  B  C  T [D] Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C [T] D  Ə  E  F  K  G
D|  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ [A] P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G [Æ] A  P  B  C  T  D
A|  P  B  C  T  D  Ə [E] F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D [Ə] E  F  K  G  Æ  A
E|  F  K  G  Æ  A  P [B] C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A [P] B  C  T  D  Ə  E

Figuring out only one fret-full of notes. The notes are the same on 1st string and 6th string. Imagine that there is a 7th string. Count one forward from the 1st string/6th string with GDAEB-KTÆƏP-FC and you'll get the correct note for the 2nd string:

E|  F  K  G  Æ  A  P [B] C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E
B|  C  T  D  Ə  E  F [K] G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B
G|  Æ  A  P  B  C  T [D] Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G
D|  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ [A] P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D
A|  P  B  C  T  D  Ə [E] F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A
E|  F  K  G  Æ  A  P [B] C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E
B|                   (K)

Circle of 5ths. Again, count with GDAEB-KTÆƏP-FC, all way up from the 6th string to the 1st string, remember the one fret jump on the 2nd string:

E|  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F [K] G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E
B|  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P [B] C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B
G|  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə [E] F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G
D|  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ [A] P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D
A|  P  B  C  T [D] Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A
E|  F  K [G] Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E  F  K  G  Æ  A  P  B  C  T  D  Ə  E

If one deliberately needs to determine whether it's a sharpened or flattened note, one could go with those previous suggestions of adding -eesh (sharp) and -eef (flat) to the the notes (-eesh/-eef only determine whether it's a flattened note or sharpened note, those names, -eesh/-eef, do not themselves flatten or sharpen the notes in this system, as there are already the names T Ə K Æ P for flattened/sharpened/black notes):
C# = Teesh, D# = Əeesh, F# = Keesh, G# = Æeesh, A# = Peesh
Db = Teef, Eb = Əeef, Gb = Keef, Ab = Æeef, Bb = Peef

NOTE: There is also similarities between sharp notes and the natural notes: A# D# G# C# F# A D G C F

But I'd rather go with the flat note based system, PƏÆTK-BEADG-CF. BEADG (mnemonic: "bead-G" or "bitchy") or BEADG-CF (mnemonic: "bitchy cipher") is also pronounced more easily and more easily remembered than ADGCF.

phoog
  • 16,807
  • 2
  • 33
  • 61
alex
  • 11
  • 2
  • 1
    Wow! Are you sure you didn't mean to post this on the [Conlang stack](https://conlang.stackexchange.com/)? – Theodore Nov 17 '22 at 22:12