1

Is the worst B/W ratio you can get in a "natural" tournament a Swiss 5 round with lifted color check in the last round, BBWBB? (Did that actually happen in real life?)

(Obviously, you can get 100% Black with "unnatural" events - all White opponents forfeiting, a tournament just with one or two rounds, feel free to comment...)

Hauke Reddmann
  • 14,860
  • 2
  • 24
  • 61

1 Answers1

1

According to the FIDE handbook (C.04.1 Basic rules for Swiss Systems):

For each player the difference between the number of black and the number of white games shall not be greater than 2 or less than –2.
Each system may have exceptions to this rule in the last round of a tournament.
No player shall receive the same colour three times in a row.
Each system may have exceptions to this rule in the last round of a tournament.

And according to the FIDE handbook (C.04.3 FIDE (Dutch) System):

non-topscorers (see A.7) with the same absolute colour preference (see A6.a) shall not meet (see C.04.1.f and C.04.1.g).

An absolute colour preference occurs when a player’s colour difference is greater than +1 or less than -1, or when a player had the same colour in the two latest rounds he played. The preference is white when the colour difference is less than -1 or when the last two games were played with black. The preference is black when the colour difference is greater than +1, or when the last two games were played with white.

So how can you legally get a better ratio than what you propose? Longer tournaments are out; the longer you go the more times you'll have to play White in order to keep it within 2. The obvious way would be a 3 round tournament, but that seems awfully short and on the edge of your "unnatural" 1 or 2 round tournaments.

But a 3 round tournament isn't the only way you could play 3 games. You could have a player in a 4 round Swiss with a first-round bye. The colors could then go XBBB. This would seem to be somewhat improbable, however, since any players who had played all the games would have a weaker color preference in the last round. You'd need multiple people at XBB going into the last round that have to play each other.

D M
  • 18,051
  • 39
  • 87
  • Would be (peripherically :-) interesting to actually construct such a tournament in a Swiss programm. (Unfortunately the FIDE rules only state that color check *may* overruled in the last round, but not *what* can overrule. Surely not whim of the organizer :-) The other 15 pairing rules? But that is stuff for a new question...) – Hauke Reddmann Oct 13 '22 at 20:14