Reviews of Books

Law School slands sponsor and which it has listed as No. 3 in its series of publi cations. The treatment of the constitu tional questions is logical and convinc ing Four possible methods of making federal incorporation compulsory are discussed. Two of them, exclusion of products of state corporations from inter state commerce and exclusion of their matter from the mails, the author thinks of questionable constitutionality as in fringing the equal protection of the laws. Of the other two, the writer gives his preference to exclusion of. state corpora tions from interstate commerce, though he considers that taxation of interstate commerce transacted by state corpora tions would be equally constitutional. Other phases of the subject are also discussed, and in the concluding chap ter a clear definition of interstate com merce is attempted.

517

One of the most interesting of recent bar association reports is that of the last annual meeting (1913) of the Illinois State Bar Associa tion. So much discussion of the subject of pro cedural reform in Illinois took place at the ses sions that the volume contains much that is worthy of attention. Besides the extended de bate the papers delivered by President Harry Higbee, William E. Higgins of Kansas, Herbert Harley and Albert M. Kales, all touch various phases of the general topic of procedure and the administration of justice. Of the committee reports included, one of the more significant is that of the Committee on Legal Education, in which the chairman, Dean John H. Wigmore, presented a strong dissenting opinion in which he urged that more adequate recognition be paid to the laxity of requirements for admission to the bar in Illinois.

BOOKS RECEIVED

The Thirteenth Juror: A Tale Out of Court. By Frederick Trevor Hill, author of Lincoln the Law yer, The Accomplice, etc. Illustrated by Gordon Grant. Century Co., New York. Pp.211. ($1.20 net.) Public Opinion and Popular Government. By NOTES A. Lawrence Lowell. President of Harvard Univer of itAmerica The Income Analyzed Tax Law and ofClarified," the United by Alber State 8 sity. American Citizen Series, edited by Albert Bushnell Hart, LL.D. Longmans, Green & Co., New York and London. Pp. xiv, 303 + 112 (appen H. Walker of the New York bar, is a pamphle* dices and index). ($2.25 net.) of 132 pages, in three parts. The first is a very Politician, Party and People. Addresses deliv clear analysis and criticism of the new federal ered in the Page Lecture Series, 1912, before the Income Tax, calling attention to many problems Senior Class of the Sheffield Scientific School, Yale University. By Henry Crosby Emery, LL.D., Pro of construction, with suggested interpretations. fessor of Political Economy in Yale University. The second part is an attack upon another Yale University Press, New Haven, Conn.; Oxford pamphlet issued by another author shortly after University Press, London. Pp. 173+ 10 (index). the Act took effect. The third part is the text ($1.25 net.) A Treatise of the Modern Law of Evidence. of the Act. The pamphlet will prove enter taining and instructive to all students of the new V. 4, Relevancy. By Charles Frederic Chambeiof the Boston and New York bars, American federal Income Tax. (Privately printed, New layne, editor of Best's Principles of the Law of Evidence, York, 1913.) American editor of the International Edition of Best on Evidence, American editor of Taylor on The Proceedings of the 36th annual meeting Evidence. Matthew Bender & Co., Albany, N. Y. of the New York State Bar Association, held at Pp. xxxv, 1148 + index to all four volumes 335. Utica last January, contain much important (828 for the 4 vols.) matter on the judicial recall and popular criti A History of Continental Criminal Procedure, cism of the courts (see 25 Green Bag 127). These with Special Reference to France. By A. Esmein, were not the only subjects to receive extended Professor in the Faculty of Law of Paris. Trans by John Simpson, of New York; with an edi and noteworthy discussion, and the printed re lated torial preface by William E. Mikell, Professor of port shows what serious attention was given to Law in the University of Pennsylvania, and intro such topics as uniform procedure in federal ductions by Norman M. Trenholme, Professor of courts, arbitration of the Panama Canal tolls History in the University of Missouri, and William Riddell, Judge of the High Court of Jus question, revision of civil practice in New York, Renwick tice for Ontario. Continental Legal History Series, bipartisan nominations for judges of the Court v. 5. Pp. xlv, 606 + 34 (appendices and index). of Appeals, workmen's compensation, etc. (84.50 net.)