7

I spent 8 to 10 hours a day programming on my 13.3" laptop and developed symptoms like red eyes, blurred vision, dry eyes, pain and irritation. To understand the cause of problem I visited a eye specialist and he diagnosed CVS. Now he suggested some exercises, medication, right posture, correct chair height etc. in addition he advice having a bigger Computer display (for bigger font size.)

Buying a bigger screen was on my card for sometime and doctor's advice made it a immediate priority. So I started googling trying to understand what should I consider before buying a monitor.

I could only zero down on the size (20") and LED.

I am looking for suggestions from fellow programmers who spend considerable time in front of their screens what factors like resolution, pixel density, panel technology, display colors and so forth they have taken into consideration before making their choices.

P.S

  1. I am not looking for advice on CVS.
  2. I am looking for answers focused on best display technology (computer monitor) for programmers (people having prolonged exposure to display screen)
Gaurav Agarwal
  • 921
  • 5
  • 17
  • 30
  • I'm not really convinced that this is NC. It isn't a "Is X better than Y?" or "What should I buy?" question. While it does involve an extended treatment of facts, its something thats fairly objective and involves discussion of tech that isn't gonna go away any time soon. That said, this and the other question I linked might make a great blog entry ;) – Journeyman Geek Sep 18 '12 at 00:11
  • 2
    Mentioning your experience as Computer Vision Syndrome hides away the actual symptons and what else you have taken into consideration, drawing the simple conclusion that buying a new monitor is going to help you get lost of this condition is solely a guess. You are better off taking a rest every now and then, making sure your room lightning is well, making sure the air and ventilation is correct (aka, no direct or indirect air blowing in your eyes). As for the monitor; it's not about the factors, it's about how you use it. Go for a quality one and configure it well, so you don't have to worry. – Tamara Wijsman Sep 18 '12 at 00:22
  • The reason I have thrown in the last close vote on "not constructive" is because you're taking the bold assumption that "CVS" means "buy a new monitor", the American Optometric Association [indicates no such thing](http://www.aoa.org/x5253.xml). Read through that article to get an idea what's causing the symptons your experiencing and how to actually resolve them, *configuring* your screen is perhaps one part of it but carefully choosing which one to buy is not. Furthermore, if you research what the terms in the tech specs mean, you can fairly simply determine whether one is good for you... – Tamara Wijsman Sep 18 '12 at 00:31
  • Also, in the non-generic form (that doesn't have the [XY problem](http://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/66377/what-is-the-xy-problem) present) this is a possible duplicate of [Main differences to the eyes between LCD and CRT monitors](http://superuser.com/questions/454922/main-differences-to-the-eyes-between-lcd-and-crt-monitors) (as indicated by Journeyman Geek) so it's worth checking that one out as it most likely answers your question. Also see [How do you determine what a good monitor is](http://superuser.com/questions/18141/how-do-you-determine-what-a-good-monitor-is). – Tamara Wijsman Sep 18 '12 at 00:43
  • Especially if you wear glasses, the height of the monitor is as important as anything. The top of the monitor should be above eye level. (This is a definite problem when using a laptop.) – Daniel R Hicks Sep 18 '12 at 12:19
  • 2
    To me this is a medical question, not a technological question – Keltari Sep 18 '12 at 16:38
  • 1
    I think this is off-topic for the simple reason that it's too localised. We are not medical professionals. This is a subjective question. Plus, correlation is not causation. If I could change my vote, it would be for "too localised". –  Sep 18 '12 at 16:45
  • 3
    @codingcrow - I still don't think this is the right site for your question. It's fascinating, and I think it has merit, as I'm a migraine sufferer, but *not here*. Because it's very subjective, I don't think any editing is going to make it appropriate to the site. Personally, I have 4 computer screens with radically different resolutions and density, not to mention the Retina displays on my iDevices. Brightness and contrast, dot pitch, grey-to-grey refresh, it's all very subjective, and on some days, I can't look at one but I can look at another. Maybe I too have undiagnosed CVS, who knows? –  Sep 18 '12 at 21:51

2 Answers2

2

Well, here are a few points to consider:

  1. How big do I want my screen to be?
    Up to 17" is good for single tasks. More is usually when you do CAD or if you use multiple programs at the same time. E.g. have a programming environment open + the relevant manual pages next to it.

  2. Do I want one screen or two? This is mostly a personal choice. People who tend to put applications full screen usually want two monitors so they can work with two programs. People who know the advanced skill of resizing a window might be better off with a single big screen.

  3. How fine do I want my screen content to be? (In pixels per inch).

  4. What vertical resolution do I want? (Alternative: How much do I want to avoid scrolling. Personally I always go for 1200 pixels vertical resolution on 24" screens).

  5. How well does it need to display colours?

  6. From which angle will I look at the display and will I rotate the screen a quarter?

    There are three ways of building a modern display panel. All three have different patterns matching the above three questions.

    There are TN panels. These are relative cheap to build. They refresh quickly (good for games and movies). They also have relative poor viewing angles. Neither of these matter if you sit behind one and use it for coding. It you put a TN monitor to the side (e.g. as a second monitor containing documentation) or if you rotate it (or both to get a A4/paper format monitor next to you) then it gets harder to read.

    Other panels on the market are based on IPS. This is more expensive, but yields good colours (important in design) and has excellent viewing angles.

    A third panel method is PVA. I do not know enough of this technology and I rarely see them on the market.

    Summary: think about points 5 and 6. Then decide on TN or IPS based displays.

  7. Monitor features: Does to monitor have a stand which allows it to change height?

  8. Monitor features: Does to monitor have a stand which allows it to rotate?

  9. Connectivity: (Ancient VGA? DVI? Display port? HDMI)?

    • VGA: VGA is old: Do not bother with this on any modern monitor.
    • DVI: Replaced VGA. Works up to resolutions of 1920x1200. Check carefully if you use higher resolutions than that.
    • DisplayPort: Current interface: Replaced DVI. Works perfectly.
    • HDMI: Basically DVI+sound+DRM. Sometimes the DRM kicks in, which is why I prefer displayport over HDMI. Both should be the same qua performance.
    • Thunderport: DisplayPort and an external PCIe line in one. Very cool stuff, but rather new, still rare and still expensive. (People reading this after 2012 will probably laugh and smile and say prices went down over time).

  10. LED or Fluorescent?
    There are a few small lamps in the rear of your monitor. Usually these are small TL tubes. Some modern ones use LEDs. These LEDs use less power, but can only be turned on or off. To effectively dim them they are rapidly powered on and off via a method called http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulse-width_modulation">pulse width modulation. This pulsing is said to irritate some people. For more information on that, see this site. (It is way too much text to paste here).

  11. Last but not least: Price. How much do you want to spend?

I am sure there are a few more points which I missed. But this is a start. :)

Ben Walker
  • 115
  • 5
Hennes
  • 64,768
  • 7
  • 111
  • 168
  • http://superuser.com/questions/454922/main-differences-to-the-eyes-between-lcd-and-crt-monitors/454931#comment562730_454931 might also be of interest. (original link was mispasted oops!) – Journeyman Geek Sep 17 '12 at 23:34
  • 1
    @Hennes: It's like giving meat to a vegetarian. Furthermore, I'm missing some facts, references, or specific expertise in your question. What's `17` based upon in `Up to 17" is good for single tasks`? Or `Sometimes the DRM kicks in`, please elaborate? And why does `their control method (pulses)` ... `irritate you`? This is a perfect example of what makes this question not constructive. – Tamara Wijsman Sep 18 '12 at 00:58
  • I like VGA for my 1280x1024 development monitor screen. Plus VGA is analog, not digital, so I made a 20 foot cable that plugs Ito my TV when I want to work there. – Cole Tobin Sep 18 '12 at 16:29
  • VGA can be just is fine. However you need a better than average quality cable for high resolutions or you get ghosting. And the design where you take digital information, convert it to analog, pass it over a cable and then convert it back is just 'wrong'. There is not reason do to the signal shuffle when you can pass plain digital information between two devices. (Then again, that is as subjective as looking under the hood of a car and cursing a mess of cables, while praising cars which use cable management. Most people will not even notice that). – Hennes Sep 18 '12 at 16:33
  • For argument's sake, changes in voltage representing different states, is the same for both analog and digital transmission, until you get to optical. – JoshP Sep 18 '12 at 17:29
  • 1
    While I have a multi-monitor setup (more than "to" (sic) of them) and fit into the category of people who prefer running apps maximised, that's my personal preference and certainly not due to a lack of knowledge about the arcane art of resizing "a windows" (sic). Try not to sound so condescending in future. – Karan Sep 18 '12 at 18:33
  • There are other good points to consider for configuration of the monitor itself and your work area. I stare at the computer all day as I'm a verification engineer (I say "programmer" to those that don't know what a verification engineer is) so I've done a lot of tweaking and trial-and-error, plus drawing on what knowledge I have of human eyesight, to figure out what works well.. Should I edit these in or just create a new answer? – Ben Richards Sep 18 '12 at 18:46
  • @Karan: I am not trying to be condescending. At my last job about 1 in 3 people in finance really did not know they could do that. Some of them even had two physical computers so they could copy data from one program to another program running on another computer. And yes, I mean by manually entering what they read from the other screen. – Hennes Sep 18 '12 at 19:00
  • @Hennes: Be that as it may, a re-read *still* makes it look that way to me. You could have simply written, "People who prefer running applications maximised *[note: not all apps can run full screen]* might benefit from using a multi-monitor setup so they can work better with multiple programs at once. On the other hand, people who prefer resizing and moving windows around might be better off with a single big screen." – Karan Sep 18 '12 at 19:10
  • @sidran32 Your choice, but I guess a new answer may be better. – Gaurav Agarwal Sep 18 '12 at 20:24
  • @codingcrow Yeah, I wasn't sure which would be better. But sure, sounds good. – Ben Richards Sep 18 '12 at 20:42
2

Instead of buying a new monitor, there are a few things that you can do right now to improve comfort, just through configuring your environment and monitor settings. I've done combinations of these things both for my own self (I'm a verification engineer and am staring at computer screens all day, myself), and my parents (my mother has eye problems and can't see small details very easily).

Things you can do:

  1. Change the brightness of the elements on your screen. If you're working in a text editor a lot, chances are that you're staring at a big block of mostly white for many hours in the day. This tires your eyes out quite easily. It's better to keep most things (like the background) dim and only highlight the things you need to see. That means choose a dark scheme for the programs you're using often, desktop background, and window borders. Less stimulation of your optical nerves mean they can relax more and are able to work more efficiently when actually needed. It's similar in concept to how after a while you stop recognizing a smell if it's persistent, because the nerves are being constantly stimulated and accomodate, to expend less energy. Similarly, try raising/lowering the brightness of your monitor until you reach a comfortable level. If your ambient light is dim, then you want to dim the computer monitor accordingly. If it's bright, then raise the brightness. Bring the contrast up too only enough that you can easily distinguish details on your screen. You don't want to be squinting or staring too hard to see what you need. But you also don't want to have the equivalent of a lightbulb shining directly at your face. With lots of very bright small details on a very dark background, your eyes have difficulty adjusting, which can lead to eyestrain.

  2. Change the color balance of your screen You can do this through Windows, to a degree, but this is best configured on the monitor itself. It is much easier for your eyes to distinguish colors closer to the red-orange-yellow side of the spectrum, than blues. This is simply because you have more receptors in your eyes for yellow than blue. This can be demonstrated by using a cell phone in a very dark room that illuminates the keypad with blue LEDs, and comparing it to one that uses a different color. The blues are harder to focus on. So, try changing your monitor color profile to "warm" or something that has less blue and more orange/yellow. Similarly, avoid using blues a lot on your screen when configuring your environment's color schemes. This actually cuts down on eye fatigue quite a bit.

  3. Change the size of your on-screen elements Many people will just lower the resolution, but I prefer to use the OS settings to change text and on-screen element size. This way, you will still see things zoomed in, but you won't get the blockiness that comes with zooming in pixels individually. Curves and text will be larger and remain crisp, so details will be more distinguishable.

  4. Don't sit too close to the screen If you can, put your monitor as far away as is comfortable. When it's close, your eyes have to work harder to focus on it. This can aggravate conditions like near-sightedness and contributes to eyestrain, as well.

  5. Increase your refresh rate Eyestrain due to low refresh rate is more easily apparant in CRT displays, because the flicker was more noticeable due to the way they operate. However, it still is something that can play a role even in LCD displays. The refresh rate controls how quickly the image on your screen refreshes, or updates. On a CRT display, 60 Hz was considered the bare minimum, though at that point you would also begin seeing flicker. I usually would recommend bumping it up to at least 75 or 85 Hz on a CRT monitor. LCD displays are a bit more forgiving, as there isn't flicker so much as "choppiness" in the image as it moves. The default in most monitors is 60 Hz, and usually you can't go higher than that. However, if you can, try and put it to 120 Hz. Movement on the screen is much smoother and more natural. Your eyes will thank you for it.

  6. Enable desktop composition By this, I am referring to things like Aero in Windows 7, or Compiz on Linux. I believe Mac OSX has it on by default, all the time (I'm not sure, however, since I don't own one). Aside from giving you eye candy, it makes changes on the screen due to window movement and opening/closing dialogs and windows smoother. Both Aero and Compiz can have opening/closing windows and other screen elements fade in and out instead of just popping in and out instantly. This is less of a shock to your eyes, especially if you have a dark screen and a white window suddenly opens. Also, because you're using your GPU to draw the screen instead of the CPU, screen elements will draw more smoothly and you won't get things like image tearing or partial renders.

  7. Take occasional breaks! You don't want to be staring at the same thing for too long. Look around often, get up and walk a bit. This is good for you for multiple reasons, but getting away from the computer and letting your eyes relax and focus on objects at various distances can help keep them from getting tired and strained.

Ben Richards
  • 12,697
  • 11
  • 55
  • 72